SPD Tech Circuit Protection Devices & Solutions
中文

Overvoltage Selection & Coordination

· 14 min
OvervoltageCoordinationSPDDecision tree

From surge sources and waveforms to a decision logic across SPD/MOV/TMOV/GDT/TVS/ESD, plus energy coordination and the Up cascade rule for multi-stage protection.

Overvoltage Selection & Coordination

Where Overvoltage Comes From

Good selection starts with knowing the enemy. Overvoltage on a circuit falls into four classes:

Source Typical waveform Magnitude Example
Lightning induction/strike 10/350 µs, 8/20 µs kA currents service entrance, rooftop gear
Switching overvoltage slow front, oscillatory several kV switching large loads, inductive
ESD human body 150 pF / 330 Ω ±15 kV contact human touches a port
Transient surge (coupled) 10/1000 µs, combination wave hundreds V–kV inductive loads, long-line coupling

The waveform decides which device: high energy/current → GDT/MOV; fast and precise → TVS/ESD.

Device Division of Labor

Device Response Current/energy Residual Best at
GDT µs huge (kA–tens kA) mid stage 1 / comms
MOV ~25 ns large mid-low stage 2 / power
TMOV ~25 ns large mid-low safe mains MOV
TVS ps mid very low stage 3 / signal & power
ESD ps small very low interface static

Note

There is no "universal device." GDT has huge current but high residual and slow response; TVS is fast and precise but cannot absorb large energy. Only coordination covers both.

Selection Decision Tree

What interface is being protected?
├─ AC/DC power entry (high energy)
│   ├─ main distribution → Type 1/1+2 SPD (MOV+GDT, Iimp/In by lightning zone)
│   ├─ sub-distribution → Type 2 SPD
│   └─ in-equipment → Type 3 + board-level TVS
├─ comms/signal line (low capacitance)
│   ├─ external/primary → GDT (or GDT+MOV)
│   └─ board interface → TVS / ESD array
└─ high-speed data (USB/Ethernet/HDMI)
    └─ ultra-low-cap ESD array (<0.5 pF)

Three Coordination Principles

  1. Energy coordination (decoupling): the upstream stage absorbs most energy; the downstream only handles the remainder. A decoupling element (inductor/resistor/lead inductance) between stages lets the upstream act first. Without decoupling the downstream fires first and gets destroyed.
  2. Up cascade: the upstream Up (residual) should be ≤ the downstream Up. E.g. SPD residual 1.2 kV, equipment TVS residual 30 V—decoupling grades the energy between them.
  3. Decreasing thresholds: from line to ground, each stage's breakdown/action voltage should step down, forming a "graded diversion."

Key reminder

The classic symptom of failed coordination: the equipment-side TVS burns out repeatedly while the upstream SPD is fine. Root cause is insufficient decoupling—energy wasn't eaten by the upstream. Follow the vendor coordination table or add decoupling.

Parameter Checklist

  • [ ] max line operating voltage → Uc / Vwm
  • [ ] equipment withstand Uw → Up / Vc (20% margin)
  • [ ] expected surge level → In / Imax / Ipp / Ppp
  • [ ] install position → Type 1/2/3 and device mix
  • [ ] inter-stage decoupling → inductor/resistor/lead length
  • [ ] mains MOV → use TMOV (fire safety)
  • [ ] SPD front end → SCPD backup

Next


Where Overvoltage Comes From

Good selection starts with knowing the enemy. Overvoltage on a circuit falls into four classes:

Source Typical waveform Magnitude Example
Lightning induction/strike 10/350 µs, 8/20 µs kA currents service entrance, rooftop gear
Switching overvoltage slow front, oscillatory several kV switching large loads, inductive
ESD human body 150 pF / 330 Ω ±15 kV contact human touches a port
Transient surge (coupled) 10/1000 µs, combination wave hundreds V–kV inductive loads, long-line coupling

The waveform decides which device: high energy/current → GDT/MOV; fast and precise → TVS/ESD.

Device Division of Labor

Device Response Current/energy Residual Best at
GDT µs huge (kA–tens kA) mid stage 1 / comms
MOV ~25 ns large mid-low stage 2 / power
TMOV ~25 ns large mid-low safe mains MOV
TVS ps mid very low stage 3 / signal & power
ESD ps small very low interface static

Note

There is no "universal device." GDT has huge current but high residual and slow response; TVS is fast and precise but cannot absorb large energy. Only coordination covers both.

Selection Decision Tree

What interface is being protected?
├─ AC/DC power entry (high energy)
│   ├─ main distribution → Type 1/1+2 SPD (MOV+GDT, Iimp/In by lightning zone)
│   ├─ sub-distribution → Type 2 SPD
│   └─ in-equipment → Type 3 + board-level TVS
├─ comms/signal line (low capacitance)
│   ├─ external/primary → GDT (or GDT+MOV)
│   └─ board interface → TVS / ESD array
└─ high-speed data (USB/Ethernet/HDMI)
    └─ ultra-low-cap ESD array (<0.5 pF)

Three Coordination Principles

  1. Energy coordination (decoupling): the upstream stage absorbs most energy; the downstream only handles the remainder. A decoupling element (inductor/resistor/lead inductance) between stages lets the upstream act first. Without decoupling the downstream fires first and gets destroyed.
  2. Up cascade: the upstream Up (residual) should be ≤ the downstream Up. E.g. SPD residual 1.2 kV, equipment TVS residual 30 V—decoupling grades the energy between them.
  3. Decreasing thresholds: from line to ground, each stage's breakdown/action voltage should step down, forming a "graded diversion."

Key reminder

The classic symptom of failed coordination: the equipment-side TVS burns out repeatedly while the upstream SPD is fine. Root cause is insufficient decoupling—energy wasn't eaten by the upstream. Follow the vendor coordination table or add decoupling.

Parameter Checklist

  • [ ] max line operating voltage → Uc / Vwm
  • [ ] equipment withstand Uw → Up / Vc (20% margin)
  • [ ] expected surge level → In / Imax / Ipp / Ppp
  • [ ] install position → Type 1/2/3 and device mix
  • [ ] inter-stage decoupling → inductor/resistor/lead length
  • [ ] mains MOV → use TMOV (fire safety)
  • [ ] SPD front end → SCPD backup

Next